Protocol
- Create rights-cleared briefs that separate mandatory content, prohibited content, composition, dimensions, text, brand rules, and subjective preferences.
- Freeze product surface, model or mode, references, prompt, settings, seed where available, generation count, and post-processing allowance.
- Retain every generated candidate and its lineage instead of selecting showcase outputs before scoring.
- Use independent creative and rights-aware reviewers, with masked candidate identity where the interface permits a fair export.
- Publish item-level gate decisions, defects, disagreement, edit time, exclusions, and the full evidence bundle before any summary.
Planned measurements
- Mandatory brief-gate pass rate
- Prohibited-element rate
- Identity, text, and visual-defect rate
- Human edit and review burden
- Provenance-record completeness
Publication gate
The page remains preview and noindex until every gate is met.
- Input and reference rights review complete
- Brief rubric fixed before candidate generation
- All candidates and rejected outputs retained
- Creative and rights-review disagreements resolved visibly
- No aesthetic preference reported as objective product superiority
Why results are not publishable yet
These are real missing run artifacts and external review conditions—not completed evidence.
- No rights-cleared, reproducible creative-brief set and rights-cleared reference pack with stable identifiers and expected-answer records has been published.
- No candidate run has frozen the product surface, model identifier, prompt, settings, tools, region, runtime, dependency versions, and hardware or service environment.
- No completed run log records sample size, exclusions, failures, interventions, start date, end date, and the exact configuration used for every candidate.
- No versioned scoring rubric and scoring implementation have been published with examples that another reviewer can reproduce.
- No blind or independent human-review record signed by creative, brand, and rights-aware reviewers has resolved disagreements and critical-failure labels.
- No inspectable input-to-output evidence bundle exposes failed, incomplete, excluded, and successful cases rather than only selected examples.
Sources checked
Open the original pages before relying on a time-sensitive product decision.